Our History

Andrew & Elsie Redmann

The Settlement Courtyard Inn was originally built by Andrew and Elsie Redmann.  These two Milwaukee natives moved to Door County in 1959. They bought the Lakewood Lodge in Fish Creek, transforming it into the White Gull Inn.  They started the famous Door County Fish Boil and Elsie's sister,  Frances Miller, entertained the guests on her accordian.

Cherry & Pear Orchard

In 1964 Andy and Elsie sold the White Gull Inn and bought a cherry farm where the Settlement Courtyard Inn and the Settlement Shops and Galleries are now located.  In the 1970's Andrew began painting oils on weathered barn wood and opened his own gallery, later turning the tractor barns into gallery spaces to create an artisit Settlement, which is how we got our name.  

Life as a child

The activity of the day was a tractor ride with the neighborhood kids.  We ate cherries right off the tree and spent our summer days at the Fish Creek beach and our winter days downhill skiing at Nor Ski Ridge, which is now Little Sweden.  (Marise is the one front middle).

Designing the Settlement Courtyard Inn

The couple did many building projects and started their own Real Estate company.  They wanted to get back into the Inn business so in 1982 they spent two years designing the Settlement Courtyard Inn with the old world ambiance of the White Gull Inn, finally opening in July of 1984.

Building the Inn

Their three children, Andriette, John and Marise, returned home in 1984 to help build the inn.  All the varnishing, staining and finishing work was done by the kids and crew.

John runs the Inn

A new era began in 1991 when John and Marise took over ownership. To keep up with technology they put phones in the rooms, added modem access and put reservations on a computer system. They refurbished the rooms and made them more luxurious.  In 1998 John took over sole ownership and continued to update the rooms. He added satellite TV, king beds, new TV's with remotes and offered the Coach House Suite. He refurbished the inn rooms and suites and added Whirlpool Suites. In 2000 he added the large outdoor pool.

Marise continues the family tradition

In 2004, after John's passing, Marise and her family took over the running of the inn.  New in 2005 she added the Lavender Spa and lavender garden, the beer pub and wireless internet for the guests.  Since then Marise and Ken have continued to update the inn rooms and added the Garden House.  2018 marks the start of our 34th season. We are so fortunate to have such wonderful people to share our story with us.  Thank you!

Reserve Now